UNIT 4 > MODULE 1

Copyright Scenarios

  1. Students in Mr. Johnson's web design class have been given an assignment to make a personal web site. Timmy Thompson, a student in the class, loves snowboarding and wants to put some snowboarding pictures on his personal site. The only problem is that he doesn't have any good pictures of himself. So, Timmy searches for snowboarding images in his favorite search engine and finds a site with a number of good pictures he would like to use. He looks everywhere on the site, but doesn't see anything written that says the images are protected by copyright. Timmy downloads a few of the images and uses them on his personal web site on the hobbies page. Although he is tempted to try and impress other students by passing the pictures off as his own, Timmy is a man of good consciense, and under each picture he sites the source of the image to give credit to the owner. From what you have learned about copyright law, would Timmy's use of the images be acceptable?
  2. For their second project, students in Mr. Johnson's web design class have been instructed to create a web site about their favorite place. The class just finished an activity where they learned about copyright law and Mr. Johnson warns the students that points will be deducted from their final score if he finds any copyright violations. Not wanting to jeapordize his grade, Timmy Thompson, gets his parents to drive him to his favorite place and takes pictures to use on his web site. When he gets to class the next day students present their finished sites to the class. Timmy notices that Susie Simpson has used a bunch of pictures on her web site that he knows must have been taken by a professional photographer. She didn't even site the source of the images. Timmy complains to Mr. Johnson that he thinks Susie used copyrighted images on her web site. Susie defends herself, claiming that she got the images off of a U.S. government web site and was allowed to use the images without restrictions because they were in the public domain. From what you have learned about copyright law, would Susy's use of the images be acceptable?
  3. As a final project in Mr. Johnson's class, students have been tasked with creating a web site for a local business in the community. Timmy Thompson picks his aunt's restuarant since he knows that she doesn't have a web site already. While searching the Internet for ideas, Timmy comes across a stock photography web site that has some really good close up pictures of different types of food. These images would be perfect for his project, so Timmy reads the usage restrictions for the images. Timmy is excited when he reads that the images require payment for commercial use, but are offered free for not-for profit or educational use. Since he is doing the project for a school assignment, Timmy downloads the images and uses them in his project. Timmy completes the final web site and receives praise from everyone, including his aunt and Mr. Johnson, about how nice the site looks. From what you have learned about copyright law, would Timmy's use of the images be acceptable?